1: Dave Brain (10)
2: Harry Lumley (9)
3: Harry Davis (8)
4: Red Murray (7)
5: Honus Wagner (6)
6: Danny Hoffman (5)
7: George Browne (5)
8: Socks Seybold (5)
9: Ty Cobb (5)
10: Sam Crawford (4)
11: Sherry Magee (4)
12: George Stone (4)
13: Tim Jordan (4)
14: Tommy Leach (4)
15: Roger Bresnahan (4)
16: Ginger Beaumont (4)
17: Hobe Ferris (4)
18: Sammy Strang (4)
19: Mike Mitchell (3)
20: Elmer Flick (3)
21: John Kane (3)
22: Topsy Hartsel (3)
23: Nig Clarke (3)
24: John Titus (3)
25: John Hummel (3)
26: Cy Seymour (3)
27: George Gibson (3)
28: Wid Conroy (3)
29: George Rohe (2)
30: Doc Marshall (2)
31: Frank Schulte (2)
32: Harry Niles (2)
33: Danny Murphy (2)
34: Johnny Bates (2)
35: Nap Lajoie (2)
36: Jimmy Williams (2)
37: Bunk Congalton (2)
38: Dave Altizer (2)
39: Heinie Wagner (2)
40: Harry Howell (2)
41: John Knight (2)
42: Jim Delahanty (2)
43: Patsy Flaherty (2)
44: Ed Konetchy (2)
45: Johnny Evers (2)
46: John Ganzel (2)
47: Dan McGann (2)
48: Ed Abbaticchio (2)
49: Hal Chase (2)
50: Ernie Courtney (2)
51: Ed Karger (2)
52: Whitey Alpermann (2)
53: Fred Clarke (2)
54: Art Hoelskoetter (2)
55: Claude Ritchey (2)
56: Jack Hannifin (1)
57: Tubby Spencer (1)
58: Oscar Graham (1)
59: Miller Huggins (1)
60: Mike Mowrey (1)
61: Goat Anderson (1)
62: Bob Ganley (1)
63: Solly Hofman (1)
64: Jimmy Sheckard (1)
65: Harry Steinfeldt (1)
66: Joe Yeager (1)
67: Frank Chance (1)
68: Joe Delahanty (1)
69: Bill Hinchman (1)
70: Bris Lord (1)
71: Bob Unglaub (1)
72: Joe Birmingham (1)
73: Bob Ewing (1)
74: Hank Gehring (1)
75: Ed Holly (1)
76: Pete Noonan (1)
77: Dode Paskert (1)
78: Germany Schaefer (1)
79: Roy Thomas (1)
80: Ed Walsh (1)
81: Art Devlin (1)
82: Buck Freeman (1)
83: George Davis (1)
84: Red Downs (1)
85: Johnny Kling (1)
86: George Stovall (1)
87: Jake Weimer (1)
88: Jimmy Barrett (1)
89: Jack Coombs (1)
90: Lefty Davis (1)
91: Deacon McGuire (1)
92: Red Ames (1)
93: Otis Clymer (1)
94: Danny Shay (1)
95: Mordecai Brown (1)
96: Charlie Hickman (1)
97: Tom Hughes (1)
98: Hans Lobert (1)
99: Rube Oldring (1)
100: Ed Reulbach (1)
101: Denny Sullivan (1)
102: Mickey Doolin (1)
103: Bill Hogg (1)
104: Freddy Parent (1)
105: Eddie Plank (1)
106: Ira Thomas (1)
107: Cy Young (1)
108: Patsy Dougherty (1)
109: Pat Moran (1)
110: Larry Schlafly (1)
111: Bill Shipke (1)
112: Alan Storke (1)
113: Tom Needham (1)
114: Al Orth (1)
115: Spike Shannon (1)
116: Ralph Glaze (1)
117: Del Howard (1)
118: Otto Knabe (1)
119: Joe Tinker (1)