1: George Hall (5)
2: Charley Jones (4)
3: Paul Hines (2)
4: Cap Anson (2)
5: Lew Brown (2)
6: Jimmy Hallinan (2)
7: Jim O'Rourke (2)
8: Joe Gerhardt (2)
9: Jack Manning (2)
10: Tim Murnane (2)
11: Denny Mack (1)
12: Pop Snyder (1)
13: George Wright (1)
14: Charles Fulmer (1)
15: Cal McVey (1)
16: Lip Pike (1)
17: Bill Hague (1)
18: Deacon White (1)
19: John Peters (1)
20: Ross Barnes (1)
21: Jack Remsen (1)
22: Tom York (1)
23: Johnny Ryan (1)
24: Wes Fisler (1)
25: Ezra Sutton (1)