1: Herman Long (12)
2: Elmer Flick (11)
3: Mike Donlin (10)
4: Charlie Hickman (9)
5: Billy Sullivan (8)
6: Nap Lajoie (7)
7: Jesse Burkett (7)
8: Sam Mertes (7)
9: Sam Crawford (7)
10: Jimmy Collins (6)
11: Joe Kelley (6)
12: Buck Freeman (6)
13: Bill Bradley (5)
14: Jimmy Barrett (5)
15: Ginger Beaumont (5)
16: Jimmy Ryan (5)
17: Jimmy Williams (5)
18: Danny Green (5)
19: Chick Stahl (5)
20: Lave Cross (4)
21: Algie McBride (4)
22: Fielder Jones (4)
23: Honus Wagner (4)
24: Willie Keeler (4)
25: Tom Daly (4)
26: John Ganzel (4)
27: Dan McGann (4)
28: Kip Selbach (4)
29: Bobby Wallace (4)
30: Barry McCormick (3)
31: Mike Smith (3)
32: Bobby Lowe (3)
33: George Davis (3)
34: Monte Cross (3)
35: Harry Wolverton (3)
36: Fred Clarke (3)
37: Tom O'Brien (3)
38: Ed Delahanty (2)
39: John McGraw (2)
40: Topsy Hartsel (2)
41: Charlie Dexter (2)
42: Lou Criger (2)
43: Harry Steinfeldt (2)
44: Ted Breitenstein (2)
45: Hugh Duffy (2)
46: Heinie Peitz (2)
47: Jake Beckley (2)
48: Emmet Heidrick (2)
49: Noodles Hahn (2)
50: Jack Doyle (1)
51: Al Orth (1)
52: Jimmy Sheckard (1)
53: Cy Young (1)
54: Bill Keister (1)
55: Claude Ritchey (1)
56: Charlie Irwin (1)
57: Tommy Leach (1)
58: Pink Hawley (1)
59: Clark Griffith (1)
60: Hughie Jennings (1)
61: George Van Haltren (1)
62: Boileryard Clarke (1)
63: Bill Dahlen (1)
64: Ed Scott (1)
65: Tommy Corcoran (1)
66: Billy Hamilton (1)
67: Ed Poole (1)
68: Frank Bowerman (1)
69: Jack Clements (1)
70: Otto Krueger (1)
71: Jack Taylor (1)
72: Joe Dolan (1)
73: Joe Quinn (1)
74: Kid Gleason (1)
75: Fred Tenney (1)
76: Shad Barry (1)
77: Sam Leever (1)
78: Pearce Chiles (1)
79: Tom McCreery (1)
80: Kid Nichols (1)
81: Pop Schriver (1)
82: Harry Howell (1)
83: Mike Kahoe (1)
84: Jack Powell (1)