1: Bug Holliday (13)
2: Roger Connor (12)
3: Jake Beckley (10)
4: Jimmy Ryan (10)
5: Sam Thompson (9)
6: Buck Ewing (8)
7: Henry Larkin (8)
8: Jack Clements (8)
9: Perry Werden (8)
10: Denny Lyons (8)
11: Duke Farrell (8)
12: Germany Smith (8)
13: Lou Bierbauer (8)
14: Jack Crooks (7)
15: Lew Whistler (7)
16: George Van Haltren (7)
17: Bill Joyce (6)
18: Jesse Burkett (6)
19: Jack Doyle (6)
20: Ed Delahanty (6)
21: Charlie Duffee (6)
22: Eddie Burke (6)
23: Herman Long (6)
24: Dick Buckley (5)
25: George Davis (5)
26: Bill Dahlen (5)
27: Dan Brouthers (5)
28: Mike Tiernan (5)
29: Hugh Duffy (5)
30: Mike Smith (4)
31: Jocko Halligan (4)
32: Tommy McCarthy (4)
33: Billy Nash (4)
34: Frank Killen (4)
35: Tom Daly (4)
36: Lave Cross (4)
37: Deacon McGuire (4)
38: Harry Stovey (4)
39: Jimmy McAleer (4)
40: Steve Brodie (4)
41: Cliff Carroll (4)
42: Jocko Milligan (4)
43: Oyster Burns (4)
44: Bid McPhee (4)
45: Cupid Childs (3)
46: Kid Gleason (3)
47: Ben Sanders (3)
48: Jack Stivetts (3)
49: Dummy Hoy (3)
50: Danny Richardson (3)
51: Mike Griffin (3)
52: Bobby Lowe (3)
53: Billy Hamilton (3)
54: Billy Shindle (3)
55: Jack Glasscock (3)
56: Gene Moriarty (3)
57: Charlie Comiskey (3)
58: Cub Stricker (3)
59: Pete Browning (3)
60: Bob Caruthers (3)
61: Bob Allen (2)
62: Patsy Donovan (2)
63: Bill Hart (2)
64: Patsy Tebeau (2)
65: Tom Kinslow (2)
66: Curt Welch (2)
67: Farmer Vaughn (2)
68: King Kelly (2)
69: Jiggs Parrott (2)
70: Kid Nichols (2)
71: Tom Brown (2)
72: Ice Box Chamberlain (2)
73: Fred Pfeffer (2)
74: Lew Camp (2)
75: Silver King (2)
76: Walt Wilmot (2)
77: Adonis Terry (2)
78: Doggie Miller (2)
79: Tip O'Neill (2)
80: Hardy Richardson (2)
81: Charley Bassett (2)
82: Morgan Murphy (2)
83: Bill Hallman (2)
84: Hughie Jennings (2)
85: Wilbert Robinson (2)
86: Pat Luby (2)
87: Jake Virtue (2)
88: Jouett Meekin (2)
89: John Pickett (1)
90: Piggy Ward (1)
91: Bill Merritt (1)
92: Mark Baldwin (1)
93: John Clarkson (1)
94: Tommy Dowd (1)
95: Pink Hawley (1)
96: Pop Schriver (1)
97: Harry Staley (1)
98: Paul Radford (1)
99: Kid Carsey (1)
100: Tommy Corcoran (1)
101: Dave Foutz (1)
102: Ad Gumbert (1)
103: Charlie Reilly (1)
104: Tommy Tucker (1)
105: Duke Esper (1)
106: Bill Kuehne (1)
107: John McGraw (1)
108: John Ward (1)
109: Frank Bird (1)
110: Connie Mack (1)
111: Jack O'Connor (1)
112: Billy Rhines (1)
113: Cap Anson (1)
114: Tim Keefe (1)
115: Bill Hutchinson (1)
116: Jack McMahon (1)
117: Joe Quinn (1)
118: George Decker (1)
119: Pretzels Getzien (1)
120: Cy Young (1)
121: Charlie Bennett (1)
122: George Cobb (1)
123: Frank Foreman (1)
124: John Grim (1)
125: Sy Sutcliffe (1)
126: Amos Rusie (1)
127: Chief Zimmer (1)
128: Shorty Fuller (1)
129: Darby O'Brien (1)
130: George Shoch (1)